The Transformative Power of Judging Others Favorably

8 min read

Through a Favorable Lens: Nurturing Compassion and Growth in the Light of Jewish Wisdom.

From the dawn of civilization, humanity has grappled with understanding the actions and intentions of others. This pursuit often leads us to a crossroads where we must decide how to judge the actions of our fellow human beings. Do we give them the benefit of the doubt, or do we presume the worst? In Judaism, the answer is unequivocal: We are commanded to judge others favorably. This principle, found in numerous Jewish texts including the Talmud, the Torah, and the writings of revered Rabbis, serves as an essential pillar of personal character and societal interaction.

Judging others favorably, often termed as “dan l’kaf zechut” in Hebrew, is more than a piece of sage advice. It’s an integral part of Jewish law and philosophy, which is echoed in a variety of traditional Jewish sources. The Talmud (Shabbat 127b) is clear in its instruction, stating that those who judge others favorably are themselves judged favorably by God. This reciprocity establishes a divine incentive to approach judgments with benevolence.

Leviticus 19:15 further emphasizes this perspective, with an exhortation not to pervert justice. This is understood by Rabbi Shlomo Ephraim of Luntschitz, in his Torah commentary Kli Yakar, to include judging our fellow man favorably. In other words, casting a harsh judgment without sufficient evidence is a perversion of justice.

The Chafetz Chaim, a notable 19th-century Rabbi, in his book ‘Ahavat Chesed,’ builds upon this principle. He cites the verse in the Torah (Deuteronomy 15:8) “you shall open your hand to him,” interpreting this as a command to extend not only material charity but also the charity of positive judgment.

Even the text of Pirkei Avot (Ethics of Our Fathers, 1:6) advises us to “judge every person to the side of merit.” In other words, if there’s room for doubt, our inclination should lean towards positivity.

Why, one might ask, should we go to the trouble of judging others favorably? The answer lies in both our spiritual and physical well-being. Maimonides, a medieval Jewish philosopher, physician, and Torah scholar, posits in his “Hilchot De’ot” (Laws of Personal Development, 6:7) that this benevolent judgement fosters a more compassionate, understanding, and peaceful society.

From a spiritual perspective, the Talmud’s principle that God treats us as we treat others suggests a divine reciprocity. By viewing others favorably, we invite God to view us in the same light. This notion, while perhaps abstract, encourages an aspirational standard of behavior that aligns us more closely with divine mercy and benevolence.

On a psychological level, the act of judging favorably allows us to cultivate a more positive mindset. When we view others through a lens of kindness, we inherently adopt a more optimistic worldview. This attitude not only improves our interpersonal relationships but also our own mental health, reducing stress and encouraging empathy.

The ramifications of failing to judge favorably can be severe. When we judge others harshly, we risk mischaracterizing their actions, leading to misunderstandings and conflicts. This hasty judgment can damage relationships and foster a culture of distrust. In his work “Michtav me-Eliyahu,” Rabbi Eliyahu Dessler discusses how such negative judgments create an environment that is not conducive to growth, understanding, or peace.

The intricate tapestry of life’s interactions is often seen as a mirror, reflecting our own qualities, strengths, and weaknesses. The Baal Shem Tov, founder of Hasidic Judaism, expressed the idea that everything one sees or hears can serve as a moral lesson in the service of God.

The Talmud (Kiddushin 70b) further supports this concept, with the statement “Kol haposel, bemumo posel” – “he who disqualifies, projects his own defect.” This suggests that the flaws we perceive in others may actually be a reflection of our own personal shortcomings.

In this vein, Rabbi Israel Salanter, the founder of the Musar (ethical) movement, famously said, “When I was a young man, I wanted to change the world. I found it was difficult to change the world, so I tried to change my nation. When I found I couldn’t change the nation, I began to focus on my town. I couldn’t change the town and so, as an older man, I tried to change my family. Now, as an old man, I realize the only thing I can change is myself.” This realization is a testament to the interconnectedness of the world around us and our own internal states.

The mystical tradition of Kabbalah echoes these thoughts, with the concept of “projection.” It proposes that individuals project their inner spiritual state onto the outer world. As such, if one is finding fault with others, it may be a signal to examine one’s own spiritual health.

In light of the above, the act of judging others favorably becomes a tool for personal growth and self-awareness. By looking at others with compassion and understanding, we indirectly cultivate these qualities within ourselves. This sentiment is echoed in the works of Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, who encourages us to seek out the good in others as a means of discovering the good within ourselves.

Moreover, by examining our tendency to judge others negatively, we are invited to consider our own areas of growth and development. We become cognizant of our shortcomings, and with this knowledge, we can begin to rectify them. This is reflective of the Jewish concept of “teshuvah” or repentance, which fundamentally begins with the recognition of one’s own faults.

As Rabbi Akiva would teach (Pirkei Avot 1:6), we should “judge every person to the side of merit.” This potent ethic of kindness and understanding holds transformative power for ourselves and our communities.

Yet, this journey of learning doesn’t conclude here. Each day invites a new opportunity to practice this principle, challenging ourselves to see the world through a lens of benevolence. To truly internalize this, we ought to remember the Talmud’s profound insight (Shabbat 127a): the world endures because of three things – Torah study, Divine service, and acts of loving kindness. In our quest for spiritual growth and understanding, let’s aspire to embody these tenets, beginning with the way we perceive and judge others.


The exploration of the concept of judging others favorably, as informed by Torah, Talmud, and the wisdom of our sages, has been a profound journey, highlighting how interconnected our perceptions of others are to our own spiritual development. As we’ve seen, this is not just about refraining from negative judgment; it’s about active, conscious engagement with empathy, compassion, and humility, and a sincere effort to view others in a favorable light.

This practice, when integrated into our lives, can become a transformative force, shaping our character, guiding our interactions, and fostering a deep, meaningful connection with the Divine. It challenges us to rise above our initial perceptions and to explore the complexity and nuance inherent in each individual. In doing so, it brings us closer to emulating Divine mercy and justice.

Embracing this Jewish ethical principle serves as a beacon, guiding us in our interactions with others, promoting unity and mutual understanding, and nurturing our own personal growth. As we cultivate this perspective, we not only better the world around us, but we also refine our own character and deepen our relationship with God.

Through the practice of favorable judgment, we are offered a path to engage with the world and ourselves in a meaningful, enriching manner. It encourages us to continually seek truth, understanding, and growth, reflecting the divine image within each one of us. As we continue on this journey, may we always be inspired by the wisdom of our tradition and strive to live by its guiding principles.

Importance of judging others favorably

1. Rambam (Maimonides) in his “Hilchot De’ot” (Laws of Personal Development, 6:7), also underscores the need to judge others favorably, especially those who are righteous or who have an established track record of good behavior.
2. The Chofetz Chaim’s work “Chofetz Chaim: Loving Kindness” further expands upon the theme of judging favorably as an act of kindness and as a requirement for preserving peace and harmony.
3. Sefer Chasidim (an ethical text by Rabbi Judah ben Samuel of Regensburg) in chapter 52 speaks about the importance of judging others favorably and the spiritual benefits it brings.
4. Rabbi Eliyahu Dessler, in his work “Michtav me-Eliyahu,” shares deep insight into human psychology and relationships, emphasizing the importance of favorable judgment to build a positive, loving society.

Additional Sources
1. The Talmud (Shabbat 127b) mentions the importance of judging others favorably, stating that those who judge others favorably are themselves judged favorably by God.
2. Leviticus 19:15 instructs us not to pervert justice, and Rabbi Shlomo Ephraim of Luntschitz, in his Torah commentary Kli Yakar, elaborates that this includes favorably judging our fellow man.
3. The Chafetz Chaim, in his book ‘Ahavat Chesed’ cites the verse in the Torah (Deuteronomy 15:8) “you shall open your hand to him”, which he interprets as referring not only to charity but also to judging others favorably.
4. In Pirkei Avot (Ethics of Our Fathers, 1:6), it is advised to “judge every person to the side of merit.”
5. The Baal Shem Tov is quoted as teaching: “The world is your mirror. If you see a fault in others, it is really your own fault you are seeing.”
6. Rabbi Nachman of Breslov, in Likutey Moharan (II, 112), speaks about how when we judge others unfavorably, we can create negative realities. He teaches that by judging others favorably, we actually help them ascend to that positive judgment.

Short URL:

You May Also Like

+ There are no comments

Add yours